- Sekce pro nastávající rodiče
- Sekce pro porodní asistentky
- Dotazník pro porodní asistentky 2023
- Odborná příručka pro porodní asistentky
- Dotazník pro porodní asistentky
- Okénko do zahraniční
- Srovnávací tabulka podmínek činnosti PA v zemích Evropy
- Mezinárodní setkání porodních asistentek v Praze
- Historie kurzů a seminářů s Barbarou Kosfeld
- Fotky ze semináře s B. Kosfeld v říjnu 2010 v Praze
- Fotky ze semináře s B. Kosfeld v říjnu 2011 v Praze
- Fotky ze semináře s B. Kosfeld v říjnu 2012 v Praze
- Fotky ze semináře s B. Kosfeld v říjnu 2013 v Praze
- Fotky ze semináře s B. Kosfeld v říjnu 2015 v Praze
Lecture by Katarzyna Oleś, Poland 

QUO VADIS POLISH MIDWIFERY??
Ahead I’d like to begin my story of midwifery in Poland with the political transformation of 1989. This was when a significant shift began in the way women giving birth were treated. At the time, attitudes towards medicine were shaped not only by the legacy of communism, with its principle of treating everyone the same regardless of their individual needs, but also by an outdated, patriarchal worldview. This way of thinking persisted in the medical profession for a long time, along with a rigid hierarchy and the dominant position of doctors. According to estimates, 70–80% of obstetricians at that time were men. Obstetrics was seen as a highly demanding, intervention-based specialty. This way of thinking also influenced how pregnancy and birth were understood. They were treated as processes that needed to be controlled in order to make them “safe”. The growing availability of different medical procedures was a double-edged sword. On the one hand, it made it possible to improve the safety of mothers and babies. On the other, it opened the door to interventions based on subjective decisions, for example, inducing labour simply to make a baby arrive on a particular date. During this period, the role of hospital midwives was increasingly marginalised. They worked under doctors and were not allowed to make independent decisions about the care provided during labour and birth. The term commonly used to describe their professional status was średni personel, literally “middle-level medical staff”. This says a lot about how midwives were perceived at the time. The professional position of midwives was somewhat different in smaller communities, particularly in small towns and rural areas. Local maternity units still existed there, and midwives retained a great deal of independence. They worked directly with women during pregnancy, birth and the early postnatal period, although officially their work was carried out under a doctor's supervision. Unfortunately, the growing gap between midwifery in urban hospitals and clinics and the work carried out in smaller centres eventually led to the gradual closure of these local maternity units. This was, of course, presented as a step towards greater safety and modernisation. Despite protests, the last such unit in Poland closed on 31 December 2008, after 57 years of operation. The official reason was a new set of requirements stating that every facility where women gave birth had to have an operating theatre. Midwives in Poland also provided care for pregnant women and new mothers outside hospitals. As community midwives, they visited women in their homes and taught them how to care for themselves and their babies. In the years following the Second World War, particularly in rural areas, although not exclusively there, some midwives also attended home births. This practice was not formally regulated by law and was viewed unfavourably by the medical profession, which saw it as a symbol of a traditional, backward approach to childbirth. As a result, home births gradually became less common, and by the 1970s they were already a rarity. All these developments led to a situation in which babies were born in hospital wards that families were not allowed to enter because of infection-control rules. Women were required to lie down during labour, were not allowed to eat or drink, and were subjected to one medical procedure after another. Hospital midwives were involved in carrying out these procedures. We can imagine how unsatisfying, and often oppressive, these birth experiences must have been for women and the midwives accompanying them. In many parenting and medical circles, frustration with this situation continued to grow. Eventually, it contributed to the emergence of the Rodzić po Ludzku (Childbirth with Dignity) campaign, which has already been discussed at this conference. Political changes made it possible for Polish midwives to establish direct contact with leading figures in midwifery, build professional relationships with colleagues from other countries, attend international conferences and take part in study visits abroad. Polish midwives increasingly took advantage of these opportunities. This helped bring about a change in attitudes towards the role of midwives. More and more of us began to speak openly about professional independence and the freedom it gives us to respond to women's needs in a more individualised way. Professional associations and foundations began to emerge, along with informal movements working to change maternity care. One of these organisations was Dobrze Urodzeni (Born Well), an independent initiative bringing together parents and midwives. I was one of its co-founders and later served as its president for many years. At the end of the 1990s, home birth began to regain support, and more midwives gradually became willing to support parents who chose this option. Some hospital wards opened their doors to family-centred births, and the first places where women could give birth more actively began to appear. The number of antenatal classes grew rapidly, helping parents become better informed and more aware of their options. Nevertheless, a considerable part of the medical profession, particularly doctors, remained deeply sceptical about these “new” approaches. Safety was their main argument, even though there was no research or statistical evidence to support many of their concerns. The professional position of midwives also changed significantly with the establishment of our professional self-government, the Chambers of Nurses and Midwives, and the adaptation of midwifery education to EU requirements. Gradually, more and more of our colleagues obtained university degrees, which helped raise the professional standing of midwifery. New legislation regulating our profession was introduced. First came the law governing the practice of midwifery, followed by further regulations defining standards of maternity care and the role of midwives throughout the process. It was formally recognised that midwives have the right to provide care during normal, uncomplicated pregnancies and births, including home births as part of independent practice. Our responsibilities also include caring for women during the postnatal period and looking after newborns, as well as providing education for the whole family. Later, our professional scope of practice was expanded to include prescribing certain medicines and referring patients for diagnostic tests. Midwives with academic qualifications began teaching and conducting research at universities. Women gradually gained more options when choosing how and where to give birth: from university hospitals to smaller facilities, including birth centres, and home births. Until recently, it seemed that the gradual changes in maternity care that had been taking place for almost 40 years were lasting and irreversible. Of course, many issues still needed to be addressed at a systemic level, including the funding of births outside hospitals. Many aspects of maternity care still needed improvement, but we could genuinely be proud of what we had achieved. Small signs of an unwelcome change began to appear a few years ago. Paradoxically, this happened at a time when the number of births in Poland was falling significantly. Despite the alarming demographic figures, there was a noticeable trend towards restricting reproductive rights. Examples included changes affecting access to publicly funded in vitro fertilisation and obstacles to providing the full range of prenatal screening tests. We are also seeing more and more small maternity units being closed because they are considered “not worth maintaining” due to the relatively low number of births. Instead, women are being encouraged to give birth in large hospitals, often much farther from their homes. This is happening despite protests from parents, medical staff and local communities. The quality of maternity care, the symbolic importance of the place where a child is born, and the loss of a sense of security caused by living far from a hospital all seem to matter less than economic considerations. This reveals a profound lack of understanding of what birth means to a woman, her baby and the people close to them. Once again, childbirth is being treated as little more than a medical procedure. Almost at the same time, and probably not by coincidence, the Ministry of Health decided to launch consultations on public funding for home births. This issue had been under discussion for at least 15 years. At first glance, this might seem like a step in the right direction. However, it has created considerable distrust among midwives who attend home births. Our experience of working with the National Health Fund (NFZ) does not inspire confidence. Midwives providing community care for women during pregnancy and after birth under contracts with the NFZ have to deal with overwhelming amounts of paperwork and administrative requirements, very little flexibility and constantly changing regulations. The discussions currently taking place offer no guarantee that home births will be treated differently, especially since a representative group of practising home-birth midwives has not been invited to participate. Many midwives fear that the way public funding is being introduced could ultimately reduce both the quality and the safety of home birth care. This brings us to another issue: the growing division within our professional self-government, which has existed since 1991. Membership is compulsory. The self-government was established to protect the professional standing of nurses and midwives and to address all the major aspects of our working lives, from legislation and education to social and employment rights. For many years, it fulfilled this mission. Today, however, we are seeing growing frustration with an increasingly large administrative structure that makes it difficult to respond quickly to emerging needs. Voices calling for midwives to separate from nurses and establish their own professional chambers are becoming louder, particularly in recent months. One of the main reasons is that there are almost ten times fewer midwives than nurses, making it much harder for us to ensure that our professional interests are properly represented. We face another challenge as midwives: the average age of our workforce. It is now over 54 and continues to rise. A 2022 report by the Supreme Chamber of Nurses and Midwives stated that by 2030, 60% of midwives in Poland would have reached retirement age. This situation is a serious cause for concern, above all because it threatens the continuity of the profession and our ability to ensure that new generations of midwives can replace those who are retiring. I qualified as a midwife in 1986, which means that I have now spent 40 years working in this profession. I have experienced many of these changes first-hand. I initiated some of them, supported many others, and protested against some of them. I have worked with pregnant women, women giving birth, mothers of young children and their families. I opened the first privately run childbirth education centre in Poland, and since 1992 I have attended home births. I founded and led the Dobrze Urodzeni association. I wrote articles, ran an online forum, spoke at conferences and organised them. I delivered workshops for midwives and parents. I have written three books about pregnancy and childbirth, including one for children. I have lived a truly intense professional life in midwifery during a period when Poland itself was undergoing enormous change. I believe that this experience allows me to take a step back and see the bigger picture. I can see how the way pregnant women are treated, and consequently how midwives are treated, reflects broader social attitudes and political priorities. It brings into focus our relationship with things that matter most but are not always easy to recognise or measure: respect for difference, love and spirituality. I hope that everything the world is bringing our way right now will turn out to be no more than a bump in the road on our way towards a better future! Děkuji za pozornost! Katarzyna Oleś
katarzyna_oles@poczta.fm
+48 601489686 |


